Olive Oil Facts

When I spoke on the Low Carb Cruise this past May I was fortunate enough to dine with Dr. Stephen Phinney. I was a little star struck when I met him. His book The Art and Science of Low Carb Performance was a book that changed my life and started my keto journey! At dinner he brought his own bottle of olive oil to share with the table. Right away I knew I was going to like him! I often thought I was a weirdo to question what types of fats restaurants use; especially after I was served a vegetable oil dipping “butter” for my crab.

The bottle of olive oil that Dr. Phinney brought to the table brought up a great topic; “how to choose a quality olive oil?” Some of the olive oil facts he taught all of us was really fascinating and it sent me to find the best ones to use for my family.


Mistake #1: Buying old olive oil sitting on shelves for months/years

Olive oil, unlike wine, does not get better with age. Like milk, eggs, meat, and many other foods, olive oil is perishable. The olive is, after all, a fruit. Similar to other fruit juices, olive oil is best enjoyed fresh-squeezed. That’s when you experience its peak freshness, flavor, and nutritional

My recommendation: I avoid buying olive oil in stores, where the oils can sit on the shelf for months, growing stale, musty, and eventually rancid. I much prefer buying online, where you can secure olive oils fresh from the latest harvest. That’s when olive oil is bursting with freshness!

I was interviewed on John Tesh’s radio program and he is eating keto because of his recent cancer diagnosis. His wife also eats keto now and they love to do olive oil shots with different quality olive oils!

Mistake #2: Unwittingly buying olive oil made by the Mafia.

In recent years, many of America’s most respected media, including Forbes, The Wall Street Journal, and CBS News and scores of others have reported the appalling news that many olive oils in the US are cheap counterfeits made by the Mafia. For example, last year 60 Minutes ran an explosive exposé showing how the Mafia has infiltrated the olive oil business, adulterating olive oil with much cheaper ingredients, such as nut and seed oils, to make obscene profits when they sell it as “extra virgin” (the highest grade). According to 60 Minutes, you now face a “sea of fakes” when you shop for olive oil.

This is a concern because when criminals make olive oil, they couldn’t care less about your health. In his New York Times best-selling book, Extra Virginity, journalist and olive oil expert Tom Mueller warns of contaminants and even cancer-causing agents in fake olive oils, as follows:

“Italian investigators have found hydrocarbon residues, pesticides, and other contaminants in fake oils, and pomace oil, a common adulterant, sometimes contains mineral oil as well as PAHs, proven carcinogens that can also damage DNA and the immune system. Then there’s the 1981 case of toxic oil syndrome in Spain, when rapeseed oil adulterated with an industrial additive, sold as olive oil, killed eight hundred people and seriously injured thousands more.”

My recommendation: You never want to feed your family fake olive oil made by the Mafia. But how can you avoid it? I recommend buying from a supplier who goes the extra mile of having all their oils independently lab certified to be 100% pure extra virgin.

Mistake #3: Thinking that all olive oils taste alike.

If you’ve always bought your olive oil in a supermarket, odds are you’ve never experienced the diversity of flavors that await you among the finest artisanal oils. You see, ordinary mass-market olive oils sell in such huge volume, they must combine inferior olives from many farms and different growing regions, with little regard for flavor compatibility. To my taste, this typically results in a dull, lifeless flavor profile. In contrast, award-winning artisans create their oils from olives grown on small, boutique farms. These dedicated masters are free to strive for flavor perfection from each different type of olive. This makes their award-winning creations as rich, complex, and distinctive as the finest wines.

For example, some olive varietals naturally possess a bright, spicy flavor. These oils are audaciously bold and pair magnificently with a steak or grilled lamb. In contrast, other artisanal olive oils are pressed from olives that yield softer, more delicate nuances. These will perfectly complement—without overpowering—your delicate baked halibut. Still other olives naturally yield a greener, more herbaceous oil that will crown your salad greens and veggies with breathtaking farm-fresh flavor. Discovering and enjoying these amazing differences in fine artisanal olive oils is not only fun, but as any master chef will tell you, it’s one of the great secrets of elevating your favorite dishes to new heights of flavor and satisfaction.

My recommendation: The moment you twist the cap off one of these outstanding just-pressed oils and inhale its harvest-fresh bouquet, you’ll know exactly what I’m talking about.

I love to drizzle olive oil on my soups such as this Manhattan Clam Chowder (found in Easy Dairy Free Keto cookbook).

So Where Do I get My Olive Oil? 

In my pre-keto days, I was a part of a wine club… now my new club is an olive oil club! I found this amazing small and kind company (you all know I love to support kind and small businesses!) who has a great olive oil club. My Personal “Olive Oil Hunter,” is the owner T. J. Robinson who is a gourmet chef and food writer who stared this cool idea! His club is called the Fresh-Pressed Olive Oil Club.

Joining the Club gives you direct access to the purest, freshest, and most flavorful olive oils from a wide array of gold-medal- winning olive oil producers. These olive oils are personally hand-selected by T. J. Robinson exclusively for his Club members and are available nowhere else on earth. They are out-of- this-world delicious! And when you join, there’s no commitment to buy anything else.

With T. J. as your personal “Olive Oil Hunter,” you’ll never again have to worry about unwittingly buying olive oil counterfeited by the Mafia, using fake and potentially harmful chemical additives. That’s because every olive oil T. J. imports is independently certified in two ways to be 100% pure extra virgin.

First, each oil is chemically tested by an accredited third-party laboratory and certified to be 100% pure extra virgin. Second, each oil is also certified by an independent tasting panel of human judges, formally trained and accredited to detect even the slightest defects in an olive oil’s taste or aroma. This means that if you ever have a guest for dinner who happens to be an olive oil connoisseur, you can serve them these oils with unabashed pride. You’ll know that these oils have been certified by a panel of the world’s fussiest professional judges to gloriously meet every strict requirement on their list to pronounce it 100% pure extra virgin, the highest grade.

Unlike some other clubs, there’s never a minimum commitment or obligation to buy anything. Every olive oil comes with a no-questions-asked, 100% money-back guarantee. And if you ever decide to ask for your
money back on a given shipment, you don’t even have to return the oil.

If you’d like to try this unique Club and receive one of T. J.’s $39 bottles for just $1 to help cover shipping, Click here to claim your $39 Bottle-for- a-Buck!

Instead of gifting someone a Wine Club, gift them this Olive Oil Club!

About Maria Emmerich

Maria is a wellness expert who has helped clients follow a Ketogenic lifestyle to heal and lose weight for over 12 years. She has helped thousands of clients get healthy, get off medications and heal their bodies; losing weight is just a bonus. She is the international best selling author of “Dairy Free Ketogenic Cooking” and “Keto.”.
Click here for Keto.:
Click here for Easy Dairy Free Ketogenic Cooking:


  • Loren Ewert says:

    Dear Maria,
    Thanks for the information on olive oil. I met you last Saturday in Lanesboro and bought one of your books at the Peddler cafe. I have been buying olive oil at Trader Joe’s for the past year. The oil is called “California Estate Olive Oil” and cost only $5.99 per bottle. In the Consumer’s Report Magazine for October 2012 it was rated 2nd best of all the oils they tested. Give it a try sometime. It is very good and inexpensive. I often use it to make salad dressing, one part wine vinegar and three parts oil oil.
    I am enjoying the cook book I purchased from you.
    Loren Ewert at Mankato, MN

  • Zoe says:

    We are so lucky here in Cyprus…..most people have olive trees in their yards and produce their own olive oil….i have about 10 olive trees!

Sign Up For Our Newsletter!

Never miss a recipe or post! Also get exclusive Discounts and Coupons!